Search
en  fr  de
EN
FR
DE
  1. Home
  2.  > 
    Programme
  3.  > 
    Programme 2020-2023
  4.  > 
    Home language competences
  5.  > 
    Exploratory research

Survey on the assessment of home language competences

In 2021 and 2022, the RECOLANG team carried out a European survey on the place of home languages at school, particularly in the educational pathways of migrant teenagers between the ages of 11 and 18. The survey looked at the assessment of home language competences and their role in different education systems in Europe and beyond. The survey consisted of two complementary sections aimed at two different target audiences:

A section for learners aged 11 to 18 with a history of migration and one or more home languages other than the language(s) of schooling. This section was available in 9 languages: Arabic, English, French, German, Hungarian, Italian, Persian (Dari/Farsi), Portuguese and Turkish.

A section aimed at schools and educational establishments, teaching and support teams in schools, and those involved in initial and in-service training for teachers working with this age group (11-18 year olds). This section was available in 6 languages: English, French, German, Hungarian, Italian and Portuguese.

Objectives

The aims of the survey were to gain a better understanding of:

  • whether and, if so, how the languages and cultures of learners are taken into account in schools, and for what educational purposes;
  • how language competences and their uses can be properly acknowledged as relevant to the learning pathways of young people or in the professional development of teachers.


Automatically generated English subtitles are available. Please activate them in the settings at the bottom of the video!

Video

Would you like to find out more about possible ways of integrating home languages into assessment? Watch this documentary clip on plurilingualism and assessment. 

Survey procedure

Given that very little research has been carried out internationally to understand how home languages are assessed in different contexts (Gross et al., 2020), we adopted an exploratory approach (Swedberg, 2020) aimed at generating a provisional initial analysis by collecting information from different contexts and describing the main findings. The online survey was carried out throughout 2021 and 2022 and collected data from 164 institutions and 191 learners in 47 countries.

Read more

Main results

Principaux résultats de l'enquête auprès des institutions
  • Pour un grand pourcentage d'élèves plurilingues (44 %), il n'existe pas de pratiques d'évaluation permettant de déterminer leurs compétences dans la/les langue(s) familiale(s).
  • De nombreux·euses élèves plurilingues sont évalué·e·s quant à leurs compétences linguistiques dans la (les) langue(s) de scolarisation (dans 69 % des cas) ou dans d'autres matières.
  • De nombreux·euses élèves plurilingues (36%) sont évalué·e·s dans leur(s) langue(s) familiale(s) à leur arrivée dans un nouveau système éducatif, mais rarement par la suite.
  • L'évaluation des compétences dans la/les langue(s) de scolarisation (LdS) couvre toutes les habiletés langagières.
  • Lorsqu'il s'agit d'évaluer les compétences dans les langues parlées à la maison, moins d'habiletés sont évaluées.
  • L'évaluation des langues parlées à la maison est effectuée à des fins diverses, la plus courante étant le placement des élèves dans les niveaux d'enseignement appropriés.
  • Des matériaux standardisés et non standardisés sont utilisés pour évaluer les compétences en langue(s) familiale(s).
Principaux résultats de l'enquête auprès des apprenant·e·s
  • Les résultats de l'enquête auprès des apprenant·e·s confirment que les compétences en langue(s) familiale(s) de la plupart d'entre eux ne sont pas évaluées.
  • 33 % des personnes interrogées ont déclaré avoir été évaluées dans leur(s) langue(s) familiale(s) à l'école.
  • L'évaluation des compétences déclarée a eu lieu dans une vingtaine de langues différentes (avec un pourcentage élevé d'évaluation de compétences en anglais langue première).
  • 57 % des répondant·e·s ont déclaré avoir été évalué·e·s en ce qui concerne les compétences orales dans leur(s) langue(s) familiale(s).
  • L'objectif principal de l'évaluation des compétences en langue(s) familiale(s) est lié à l'arrivée dans un nouveau système éducatif.
  • Il y a plus de langues citées pour lesquelles les compétences des apprenant·e·s n'ont pas été évaluées que de langues citées pour lesquelles les compétences l'ont été (47 contre 20).
  • Quel que soit le statut des langues parlées à la maison, les compétences liées peuvent rester non évaluées lorsqu'il ne s'agit pas des langues de scolarisation (l'anglais comme langue parlée à la maison est déclaré non évalué deux fois plus souvent qu'évalué ; il en va de même pour l'arabe. Le français comme langue parlée à la maison est 3 fois plus souvent non évalué qu'évalué).
  • Seuls 33 % des jeunes souhaitent que leurs compétences dans leur(s) langue(s) familiale(s) soient évaluées. Par ailleurs, 79 % d'entre eux souhaitent mieux apprendre leur langue maternelle.
Main results of the survey of institutions
  • For a large percentage of plurilingual learners (44%), there was no means of assessing their competences in their home language(s).
  • Many plurilingual learners are assessed on their competences in the language(s) of schooling (in 69% of cases) or in other subjects.
  • Many plurilingual learners (36%) are assessed in their home language(s) on entry to a new education system, but rarely thereafter.
  • The assessment of competences in the language(s) of schooling covers all language competences.
  • When it comes to assessing home language competences, fewer competences are assessed.
  • Home language assessment is carried out for a variety of purposes, the most common of which is to place learners at the appropriate level of education.
  • Standardised and non-standardised materials are used to assess home language competences. 
Main results of the learner survey
  • The results of the learner survey confirm that the home language competences of most learners are not assessed.
  • 33% of respondents said they had been assessed in their home language(s) at school.
  • The assessment of declared language competences took place in around 20 different languages (with a high percentage of assessment of competences in English as a first language).
  • 57% of respondents said they had been assessed on their oral competences in their home language(s).
  • The main purpose of assessing home language competences is linked to entering a new education system.
  • According to the respondents, the number of languages in which learners' competences were not assessed was greater than the number of languages in which they were assessed (47 as compared to 20).
  • Whatever the status of the languages spoken at home, the related competences may remain unassessed if they are not also the languages of schooling (English as a home language was declared to be unassessed twice as often as it was assessed; the same applies to Arabic. French as a home language is three times more often not assessed than assessed).
  • Only 33% of young people would like their competences in their home language(s) to be assessed. On the other hand, 79% would like to learn their mother tongue better.

What learners said about their home language(s) at school

In the survey, learners were encouraged to share their views on what schools are doing - or not doing - about their home languages, and what they expect schools to do to develop their languages. The following quotes illustrate what learners said.

Read more

Conclusions from the two questionnaires

There is little assessment of the home language competences of plurilingual learners taking place at schools.

Ad hoc home language assessment is extremely common.

 The extent to which schools are involved in assessing learners' home language competences depends largely on the personal interests of stakeholders (teachers, coordinators, etc.).

Read more

Consequences to be drawn from the survey results

1
Schools need more knowledge about and training in the importance of assessing learners' home language competences. With a few exceptions, this was highlighted in the institutional surveys and learners' responses, which confirmed the lack of awareness, materials and knowledge about assessing home language competences.

2
A set of evidence-based principles for assessing home language competences across Europe should be developed and shared by institutions. This could lead to a reduction in 'ad hoc' assessment that focuses primarily on assessing competences related to the language(s) of schooling.

3
Countries should collaborate on collecting and sharing different types of tools and materials for assessing various home language competences for different age groups.

4
The gap between what happens in schools, where a majority of learners say that their languages are not catered for, and the desire of these same learners to continue learning their languages should be explicitly taken into account.

Some additional results from the surveys

Institutional survey (PDF)

Learner survey (PDF)

Bibliography

Gross B., Hansen A., McMonagle S., Duarte J., García-Jimenez E., Szelei N. & Pinho A. S., "Expert evaluation on urgent research on heritage language education: A comparative study in Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Portugal and Spain", Journal of Home Language Research, 4(1), pp. 1-16, 2021, https://doi.org/10.16993/jhlr.35, accessed on 23 June 2023.

Swedberg R., "Exploratory research", in Elman C., Gerring J. & Mahoney J. (eds.), The production of knowledge - Enhancing progress in social science, Cambridge University Press, pp. 17-41, 2020.

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...